We have owned at BH (3 weeks) and CP (1) for about ten years and really enjoy the Hyatt system with its high quality resorts and flexibility. We always use our CP week 2 but always trade the BH weeks for additional CP time and to go to other HRC properties like SH, Sedona, Carmel. Many a spring break with our daughters has been at an HRC resort. We have not used II yet but will next year. The key is to put in a wait list request as far in advance as you can.
The Pinion Pointe maintenance fees are lower than all the rest because that property has a small area of shops on the property from which they collect rent to offset overall costs, a situation unique to that resort alone. So to compare MFs you have to see Piñon Pointe as an outlier.
All four of our weeks were bought resale, several during the big recession at what are now very reasonable prices, and have seen the BH weeks get a boost in points as well. We were introduced to time sharing via Disney which we bought at developer price (ouch) when our kids were small, and traded into Beach House one spring break and discovered there was a secondary market for Hyatts and never looked back.
I cannot imagine that you will be disappointed if you buy into HRC via resale.
