I am glad we were able to do the great trading we did when our kids were young. RCI's annual nonstop fee escalation for exchanges is beyond ridiculous.
Now that we are retired and empty nesters, we find that oftentimes RCI Extra Vacations are actually cheaper than using your TPUs. So, for that reason we will continue to keep our RCI membership. We usually rent our timeshare weeks we don't use, and use the cash to go where we want to go. We have a few TPU's left that we need to use, and now that RCI is reducing the combine to be only good for 12 months--- I will have to hurry to get them used up. Nowadays with Booking.com, VRBO, AirBnB, and hotels like Residence Inn, it is easy to find a nice place with a mini kitchen and book it immediately/no waiting for the exact days you need. Timesharing has spoiled us with the costs savings of being able to cook a few meals, or make some sandwiches to take on the road. But we are now finding we can often get those same amenities without it being a timeshare.
But -- we booked 3 RCI Extra Vacation weeks this year for only $199 per week, all at beach-front resorts in the shoulder season. Same price as over 20 years ago when we tooks our first RCI Extra Vacation to Puerto Vallarta in October. So I say, "why throw out the baby with the bath water"? Since RCI continues to up the costs of exchanging to ridiculous levels-- they get very little exchange business from us. We've gotten rid of all but one of our RCI timeshares that is close to our home and easy to rent. But cheap Extra Vacation weeks can definitely make having an RCI membership worth having.
We added a 2-bedroom EOY lockoff Marriott week to our timeshare ownership in 2009 and we have been really happy doing our exchanging through I.I. now instead of RCI. Yes, we now have to pay for 2 Exchange company memberships, but we enjoy getting the access to higher quality resorts through Interval International. Plus, we get 3 weeks from our 1-week deposit with Interval- we lock it off so we have the 1-bedroom side to trade, the studio side to trade, and then I.I. always puts an Accomodation Certificate into our account. Being a Marriott, Starwood, Hyatt, etc. gives you preference on other trades into your group and we have gotten some really great trades that would have cost us $400+ per night on Expedia.
So, I think timeshare exchanging is not yet TOTALLY dead, although RCI is probably one of my least-favorite corporations in the entire world. In the final anaylsis -- we all have to do the math and figure out what systems work best for us. It's seldom a one size fits all, since we have different family needs, different financial situations, and different places we want to travel.
-- Rene