So I got response back from the guy at the title company:
Good afternoon Richelle,
I received a message from them. They stated that they did not use the points. I spoke with the title specialist and this is what she told me.
Wyndham doesn't know why the points are not available in Richelle's account. The new owner needs to contact Owner Care
800.251.8736 Option 3 then 2. They need to request points audit. If Wyndham does not find that the reservations were made, or points banked thru RCI they will reinstate the points into their account.
Wyndham will be able to tell what what happened to the points. If the sellers used them Wyndham will tell you. Let me know ASAP what you find out.
Best regards, "
Gee, why didn't I think that????? I was so livid because I already told him I did that. So I politely responded back and told him that they did do an audit and they said the previous owner used the points. I decided to call owner care again and let them know what the previous owner said. The kind lady did some digging of her own and uncovered that the owners made a reservation on Feb 8th for Ocean Blvd with a checkin in August. The contract did not hit my account until Feb 24th. Regardless of how many points they had in credit pool, the reservations would have been made using the use year points first which were the 248k I was missing. So the good news is, they have a reservation they have not traveled on, so the points are not gone. I have it in writing from the title company that only 60k where borrowed from this years points, so I am owed 248k points. They can either cover my maintenance fees this year or have the previous owners talk to owner care about transferring 248k of those points used for the reservation to my account. Apparently these owners have or had a lot of points because they used points for air fare and car rentals. I cringed when I heard that. Waste of points. I past on what I learned to the title company. I told them that I wanted the previous owners to pay for the maintenance fees or for them to work with owner care to transfer those points to me. I'll take either one, but would prefer the points. I had to borrow from future years points to make the reservations i needed.