Redweek valuation?????

These numbers do not make any sense to me. I requested valuation for 2 timeshares.

Fairways of Palm Aire week 14 - 1br--1,434.

Affinia Manhattan - 1br- Thanksgiving Week - 1,130.

I would say that this disproves the theory that the credits correlate to rental value. You'd be lucky to rent Fairways of Palm Aire for $600. You could probably get 3 times that for a Manhattan rental especially during a holiday week. Wouldn't you think?

abc

One of many reports that disprove that theory!

On the OBX, they actually give a few more points for the lowest demand resort in the local t/s rental market, Barrier Island Station Kitty Hawk (even pricing weeks $100 less than standard oceanfront resorts, BIS Kitty Hawk owners generally cannot rent them at all until all of the oceanfront inventory is booked) than the same size unit during the same week at the second highest demand OBX resort, Barrier Island Station Duck.

Wacky results like these make me want to steer clear of this exchange company.

abc31 said:

These numbers do not make any sense to me. I requested valuation for 2 timeshares.

Fairways of Palm Aire week 14 - 1br--1,434.

Affinia Manhattan - 1br- Thanksgiving Week - 1,130.

I would say that this disproves the theory that the credits correlate to rental value. You'd be lucky to rent Fairways of Palm Aire for $600. You could probably get 3 times that for a Manhattan rental especially during a holiday week. Wouldn't you think?

abc

Click to expand...

I have posted on other threads about this situation. Your example seems pretty clear cut.

Not only are the redweek valuations contrary to rentasl values.

They, in my valuations given, are also contrary to RCI trading values.

I'm not sure how they derive them. Look at some Florida v's Pocono's V's cape Cod points values and see if you can explain. I have no idea and will stay away until there is some consistancy.