We own at Villas of Sedona (and it's sister resort next door, Sedona Springs). We have actually only stayed there once- and rented that time. Our grown kids and families lived in the Phoenix area and we all gathered at Sedona for Thanksgiving almost 15 years go. My, how time flies. The units there (Villas) are good size and the pool area has both in- and outdoor access depending on weather- and good BBQ areas. They also exchange via RCI.
Much of what you might consider 'Best' would depend on what you want to do. If you want to hike out directly onto the red rock trails, you might want one thing, but if you are golfers, somewhere else would appeal. The Hyatt and Los Abrigados are close to the 'action', where at most of the others, you'll have to drive a little ways into 'town'.
We see the OP is a TUG Member, so checking the reviews is an option.
Jim